Just doing a little side by side today of two Old Pulteney whiskies.
The 12yr is picture right and the 17yr on your left.
The 12yr and the 17yr (both award winning whiskies, mind you) are both, in my opinion, good stand-by whiskies. Something to keep on your shelf at all times. These whiskies are perfect for those who are not familiar the juice and nice for those who are and want something balanced, full flavored and easy going.
I just need to remark quickly on the bottle shape as I find it to be most strange. Almost as strange as their stills look. But hey, their stills produce some fine-fine spirit so let’s not make judgements upon appearance. Ok?
On to the nosing…
12yr – A bit forceful (has a bite), yet fresh and inviting.
Honey elements as well as citrus & cream (like and orange creamsicle).
A second nosing offers a salty sea breeze and some grassy notes.
Fennel seed, vanilla and a good bit of malt.
A fairly balanced nose.
This is sweeter smelling – like sweet summer flowers also, pressed flowers.
A good deal of tropical fruits.
Something woodsy in here, like white birch bark.
A bit salty like the 12yr but not oceanic, more like food-type salt.
On to the tasting (with notes on the finish)…
Nice chewy-ish mouth feel.
Salty, grassy and a touch vegetal (think celery).
Some oak in there (didn’t really get that on the nose).
A good long and dry finish.
A truly fabulous mouthfeel.
Celery (just like with the 12yr) and big old salt lick.
Baked goods with sweet icing.
Spicy as we get close to the finish.
And, speaking of finishes… A big bruiser of a finish!
Long and creamy however, very fizzy (if that makes sense).
In sum — These are two solid whiskies. No doubt about it. I did not do this side by side to pit the two against each other. I just wanted to see the differences between the two. Both are perfect summery drams. The 12yr is light and very approachable – almost like an aperitif whisky. The 17yr is more of an after dinner digestive whisky. I wont lie here though… the 12yr is really the best bang-for-your-buck whisky of the two. At about $35 (or £25 in the UK) in many markets, you can’t go wrong with it.
Special thanks goes out to Kathy Lewis-Flanigan for the generous samples!